“Eternity” takes place in an afterlife where souls have one week to decide where to spend eternity, as Joan is faced with the impossible choice between the man she spent her life with and her first love.

“Eternity” takes a classic story — a woman choosing between two men — and brings it into the afterlife. While this had the potential to go horribly wrong, director David Freyne’s film ends up being the complete opposite. “Eternity” is wildly hilarious throughout and surprisingly deep. It offers discussion about life as a whole and the love that lies within.

There is a lot to take away from “Eternity,” whether it’s cherishing the moments you have or embracing the love you desire. While much of the exploration is surface level, it does make these difficult or challenging thoughts more streamlined and accessible, which works in the film’s favor.

The movie works so well largely because of the cast. Elizabeth Olsen (Joan), Miles Teller (Larry) and Callum Turner (Luke) are all at the top of their game. Olsen is the emotional heart of the story, with a “love versus lust” scenario almost taking over her character. She brings a wide array of emotions to the screen including shock, sadness, joy and more. She conveys these expressions so effortlessly. Teller and Turner are just as impressive. Both bring charm to their respective roles. Teller is more chaotic and messy, while Turner is calm and put together. The pair bounce off each other with several laugh-out-loud moments.

The list of strong performances doesn’t stop there. Da’Vine Joy Randolph (Anna) and John Early (Ryan) both excel as well, bringing an abundance of energy to the screen and making the most of their more limited roles.

With such a cliché plot, “Eternity” does feel all too familiar at times. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing though. It takes this idea and spins it in a variety of creative ways.

The opening of the film alone showcases Freyne’s imagination. Whether it’s the ride into the afterlife, the eternity pamphlets being handed out or the paintings showing the outside world, “Eternity” makes the thought of death a little less scary.

There are still moments of inconsistency, however. “Eternity” runs 112 minutes, and it doesn’t always warrant this, specifically in the final act. The plot developments grow more predictable as the film progresses, with parts of the movie feeling extra bloated.

The makeup, costumes and set design are all top tier. “Eternity” makes the afterlife feel like its own world, filled with quirky, imaginative details. It’s also beautifully shot, with soothing color grading that results in a satisfying aesthetic. Transitioning from tight corridors to beautiful beaches to a cabin in the woods, “Eternity” captures each setting in its own striking way.

“Eternity” is the best rom-com of 2025. It’s both funny and emotional, with a group of actors at the top of their game. It takes a typical premise and transforms it into something truly original.

Rating: 4 out of 5