“Madden” follows John Madden’s journey, from his Super Bowl-winning partnership with the Raiders to becoming football’s most recognizable voice to building the Madden NFL video game.
It’s bold to make a film about a legend of any industry. Several have already come out in 2026, including “Michael,” “I Play Rocky” and now “Madden.” The prior two movies feature actors who completely embodied the icons. Jaafar Jackson — Michael Jackson’s nephew — played the King of Pop. Anthony Ippolito was given Sylvester Stallone’s blessing to portray him. Sports fans of all ages know the name John Madden, and unfortunately for David O. Russell’s film, Nicolas Cage is almost nothing like him.
Cage gained over 20 pounds for the role, with prosthetics, a bodysuit and a wig rounding out his look as Madden. While it’s not a one-to-one match, Cage’s physical appearance isn’t necessarily the problem here. It’s his voice. He incorporates some components of Madden’s well-known voice, but this mainly just sounds like an impersonation. And not a very good one. This isn’t to say that Cage delivers a bad performance — it just feels more like he was set up for failure from the start. Christian Bale (Al Davis) and Kathryn Hahn (Virginia Madden) add star power to the supporting cast. Bale goes all-in on portraying Davis, nailing his outward aggressiveness and overly loyal demeanor. Hahn has the most grounded performance of the group, balancing many moments as Cage and Bale go over-the-top.
The editing makes the film feel like a compilation of events rather than a compelling story. In this way, it’s extremely similar to “Michael,” acting as a highlight reel instead of the full tape. There are a plethora of entertaining moments within this compilation, though. The majority of laughs come after Madden begins his broadcasting career: talking over Pat Summerall, scribbling on the telestrator, opening up a turkey. Although exaggerated, these moments are when “Madden” hits its stride. Still, the movie is never able to escape from its sizzle-reel-style, with punch-ins, animated overlays and smash cuts. Some of this is excused by its mockumentary approach, but this aspect of the storytelling is kept on the back burner, which diminishes its purpose.
This all culminates in “Madden” not being a “Boom!” What should feel larger than life instead comes across as “meh.” Of course, most of this comes from the simple fact that Cage can’t live up to Madden. But it’s also because too much of the 110-minute runtime is spent on recurring gags, cameos and unnecessary flashbacks, all of which hinder the pacing. This is a shame, because Russell and Cambron Clark’s chaptered approach in the screenplay actually works. The first third is spent exploring Madden’s coaching career. The middle act delves into his broadcasting journey. The final act transitions into the Madden video game. Each segment explores a different aspect of Madden’s life, forming his overall legacy in the process.
“Madden” doesn’t have the right lead — but could anyone have lived up to John Madden? The film shows Madden’s impact on sports and pop culture as a whole without pushing the boundaries of biopics.
Rating: 2.5 out of 5

