“Supergirl” follows Kara Zor-El, who reluctantly joins forces with an unlikely companion on an interstellar journey of vengeance and justice after a ruthless adversary strikes too close to home.
Less than one year after “Superman,” we already have the second film in James Gunn’s rebooted DC Universe, and it’s Craig Gillespie’s “Supergirl.”
The central performance of Milly Alcock (Supergirl) is impressive. She plays a messy, unorthodox version of the character who stumbles over her words and on her feet. However, she is also able to switch up her delivery at a moment’s notice. This leads to the scenes of sadness, humor and power all landing more than they probably should. No matter your thoughts on this iteration of Supergirl, it’s clear that Alcock fully transforms into the character.
More often than not, though, she is reduced to one-liners that feel forced inside what should be tense sequences.
“Thanks, I needed that.”
Jason Momoa (Lobo) is the definition of “fun.” It’s not an overly memorable or earned role in this specific story, but he brings an abundance of energy when present. Eve Ridley (Ruthye) is primarily used as an exposition driver. Rather than speaking like a human, her dialogue is almost entirely robot-like. She shows up, states her intention or asks a question, then listens to the ensuing explanation.
It’s a recurring cycle of frustration, as Ana Nogueira’s script doesn’t trust the audience enough to let events play out for themselves. The screenplay is a jumbled mess, introducing new obstacles at every stop that have nothing to do with the central narrative, only there to round out the 108-minute runtime. This hinders the pacing, leaving large segments of the story feeling void of purpose. At times, it even seems the film is more interested in bringing uninformed viewers up to speed instead of telling a story about Supergirl herself.
Still, it does eventually grow into a sort of coming-of-age tale. The themes within are heavy; it’s mainly about trauma and grief but also alcoholism, coping and identity. It has room to address these topics, because unlike Kal-El, Kara Zor-El had to watch her home be destroyed, including all of the lives lost along with it. With the additional baggage, her story is inherently more tragic. While it may grow frustrating seeing Supergirl not be… super, it is a fundamental part of her journey.
“Supergirl” succeeds at wrapping a compelling narrative around these ideas, but the execution is shaky. The insertion of flashbacks and memories oftentimes feels jarring rather than necessary, arriving at random moments that halt the momentum.
It also leads to a similar problem that “Black Widow” suffered: you don’t get to see Supergirl in her complete costume until the very end. It’s not as egregious here, but fans will certainly feel the absence.
Unlike most other superhero movies, “Supergirl” doesn’t have worldwide stakes. In fact, it’s a largely personal story that remains contained to Matthias Schoenaerts’ Krem. This helps it feel different from your standard blockbuster, while also leaving it devoid of stakes in the grand scheme of this universe.
Once you do get to the spectacle, it’s choppy. The editing from Fred Raskin and Tatiana S. Riegel keeps scenes moving at a breakneck pace, though also disjointed at the same time. Fight sequences continuously cut, never achieving the smooth flow required for the choreography. And, of course, everyone has been talking about that “needle drop” moment — yes, it’s bad. It’s not a make-or-break moment for the movie, however.
“Supergirl” isn’t a major misstep, but it’s not “super” enough to propel the new DC Universe forward. Milly Alcock shines; the messy script does not.
Rating: 2.5 out of 5

