“Other Mommy” follows Bela, a young girl who forms a relationship with a sinister entity that looks just like her mother.
Many people complain that trailers spoil movies. Here, that isn’t the case. That’s because “Other Mommy” is a trailer in itself — or maybe like 10 of them. This is evident from the earliest stages, with the title card presented in classic trailer format: one letter at a time as short shots are spliced in between. Unfortunately, John Cutler and Peter Gvozdas’ editing remains this way throughout the 93-minute runtime.
Director Rob Savage presents an interesting string of scenarios. On their own, some of these moments are actually entertaining. This doesn’t mean that there’s any cohesion between them, however. Nothing lingers in “Other Mommy,” causing Nathan Elston’s screenplay to fall into a repetitive formula. Someone dies? There are no consequences. A dramatic incident occurs in a public setting? The characters leave with no questioning from others. Ursula and Russell’s young daughter leaves the room? They don’t follow her. This leaves the film in a loop where a supernatural event occurs, followed by the characters fleeing to the next location. It may not be light on jump scares, but it remains light on tension. This is due to that trailer-like approach, with all setup and no payoff.
It also carries into the more emotional aspects of the film. Cheating spouse? Let’s not mention that. Because Jessica Chastain’s (Ursula / Other Mommy) character is so unlikable, she almost makes the “other mommy” seem OK at times. There’s little reason to invest in the narrative as it progresses because of this.
Lowell A. Meyer’s cinematography is a bright spot. Mimicking how a spirit moves, shots travel through walls, shelves, ball pits and other impossible locations. While the script itself prevents true scares, the slow-moving, swirling camerawork allows for slight suspense.
Arabella Olivia Clark (Bela) delivers a believable performance. While Chastain and Jay Duplass (Russell) may steal headlines, she brings genuine childlike curiosity that works. Chastain has a creepy presence, with strange movements and manipulative delivery that feel menacing enough. She never goes completely over-the-top, which prohibits the villain from being overly memorable. Duplass conveys pure kindness through his performance, with his character showing way too much grace at times. Nonetheless, he and Clark bounce off each other well for a heartwarming father-daughter connection.
The calling card of the movie itself puts the final nail in the coffin for “Other Mommy.” While “other mommy” may be most prominent, the entity isn’t always “other mommy.” Sometimes it’s “other Kelvin” or “other Russell” or “other Bela.” This takes away from the core concept of the movie — a “regular mommy” who is already bad, so “other mommy” has to step in. Rather than executing on that promise, it ends up feeling like a gimmick.
“Other Mommy” has nothing to latch onto, featuring a chain of events with little connection. It may be pretty to look at, but everything else is ugly.
Rating: 1.5 out of 5

